The Thief's Story

www.akankshaclasses.com
CLASS X English ~3–5 marks (Supplementary Reader) Ch 21 of 28
The Thief's Story

Class 10 · English · NCERT chapter notes · Akanksha Classes

Snapshot
  • Author: Ruskin Bond — celebrated Indian author of English fiction, known for simple, humane, and deeply observant stories set in India.
  • Type: Short story (first-person narration by the thief himself).
  • Main Characters: Hari Singh (a 15-year-old thief who uses a different name each time he moves) and Anil (a young, easy-going writer aged about 25).
  • Setting: Delhi — a wrestling match venue where they meet, then Anil's modest room.
  • Central Themes: Trust and its transforming power; moral growth and redemption; the value of education; kindness as the most powerful force for change; honesty vs. dishonesty.
  • Key idea: A thief plans to rob the man who trusted and educated him — but his conscience pulls him back. Education, not punishment, changes him.
  • Board weightage: 3–5 marks — short-answer (2 marks), long-answer (5 marks), extract-based (4 marks) questions are common.
Detailed Notes

1. About the Author — Ruskin Bond

Ruskin Bond (born 1934, Kasauli, India) is one of India's most beloved English-language authors. He grew up in the foothills of the Himalayas and spent much of his life in Mussoorie. He has written over 500 short stories, essays, and novels. His writing is celebrated for its warmth, simplicity, and close observation of human nature and the natural world. Famous works include The Blue Umbrella, A Flight of Pigeons, and the collection The Night Train at Deoli. Bond was awarded the Sahitya Akademi Award (1993) and the Padma Bhushan (2014). “The Thief's Story” reflects his characteristic focus on small human dramas and the quiet workings of conscience.

2. Summary — Part 1: Hari Singh Meets Anil

The story opens at a wrestling match in Delhi. A fifteen-year-old boy introduces himself as Hari Singh — though this is just the name he is using at present; he uses a different name every month to avoid being caught. He approaches Anil, a young man of about 25, who seems relaxed, friendly, and not especially rich. Hari, experienced at sizing up victims, quickly judges Anil as an easy target — simple, careless with money, and trusting. He flatters Anil with an “appealing smile” and manages to attach himself to him as a servant.

Anil says he cannot pay him wages, but offers food and a place to stay. Hari accepts, thinking inwardly: “I'll get some money out of him. He must have some somewhere.”

3. Summary — Part 2: Life with Anil and Learning to Read

Hari begins cooking for Anil but produces a terrible first meal. Instead of scolding, Anil simply laughs and teaches him how to cook — this unexpected kindness surprises Hari deeply. Anil also starts teaching Hari to read and write: each day he teaches him a new word, and he also teaches him how to add numbers.

On his part, Hari cheats Anil at the market every day, keeping a small amount from the shopping money and pocketing it. He notes: “Anil knew I made a little money this way but he did not seem to mind.” This shows Anil is perceptive, not naive — he sees, and says nothing.

Anil earns irregularly from writing. When he gets a cheque for an article, both eat well; otherwise, both go without. Hari recognises Anil as the most trusting person he has ever worked for, and this trust begins to unsettle him.

4. Summary — Part 3: Hari Plans and Executes the Theft

One evening Anil comes home with a large bundle of notes — 600 rupees received for a book. He shows Hari the money and then tucks it under the mattress before going to sleep. For Hari, this is the moment he has been waiting for since he came to Anil.

Around midnight, after making sure Anil is asleep, Hari carefully slides the notes out from under the mattress. He feels no guilt yet — old habit takes over. He pockets the 600 rupees and slips quietly out of the room, stepping into the dark, cold streets of Delhi. He walks toward the railway station, intending to board the Lucknow Express and disappear forever.

5. Summary — Part 4: Crisis of Conscience at the Railway Station

Hari arrives at the station. He holds the stolen notes. He is about to board the Lucknow Express and vanish. But then something unexpected happens: he cannot make himself get on the train.

He sits on a bench and his mind replays everything: Anil's easy laughter, the reading lessons, the promise of becoming a literate, respected person. He thinks: “I could go to work, to an office, maybe earn an honest living.” He realises that if he runs now, he will always be an uneducated thief — clever but with no real future, always using a different name, always hiding.

The rain begins to fall. He stands in the rain, wet and shivering. The stolen notes get wet in his hand — limp and worthless-feeling. After a long inner battle, he makes his decision: he walks back.

6. Summary — Part 5: Return and Resolution

Hari returns to Anil's room before dawn and carefully slides the wet notes back under the mattress. He lies down and pretends to sleep. In the morning, Anil wakes up and behaves with complete normalcy — no accusation, no confrontation. He hands Hari a fifty-rupee note and says he will now be paid regularly. He also says: “I am going to start teaching you to write whole sentences now.”

Hari notices the fifty-rupee note is crisp and new — not one of the wet notes from under the mattress. This detail strongly implies Anil knew what had happened but chose not to say anything. Instead, he responds with a fresh start: regular pay and more education.

Hari feels “a little happiness” — not just for the money, but because he has done the right thing and he knows that learning to read properly is worth more than 600 rupees. He is resolved to live differently.

7. Title Significance

The title “The Thief's Story” is deliberately simple and layered:

  • It signals immediately that the narrator is a thief, placing us inside an unusual moral perspective — we see the world through the criminal's eyes, which generates unusual sympathy.
  • The irony is that the “thief's story” turns out to be a story of conscience, not crime. The most significant event is the non-crime — the decision NOT to steal.
  • The possessive form “Thief's” signals ownership of the narrative: this is his transformation, his growth. By the end, the reader wonders whether the label still fits him.
  • The title invites us to question how we label and judge people — and whether those labels can change.

8. Themes

  • Trust as a transforming power: Anil never locks his money, never accuses Hari openly. This absolute trust is more powerful than any punishment — it makes Hari unable to fully betray it.
  • Redemption and moral growth: People can change, not through fear or force, but through genuine goodness in those around them. Hari's decision to return the money is his first real step toward redemption.
  • The power of education: What pulls Hari back is the realisation that he is learning to read and write — a door to a new identity, one that is not dependent on theft, running, and constant aliases.
  • Honesty vs. dishonesty: The story contrasts Hari's habitual dishonesty with Anil's transparent generosity — and shows that honesty is the more fulfilling and lasting path.
  • Kindness as the most effective reformer: Anil's patient, non-judgmental kindness — laughing instead of scolding when the food was bad — reaches Hari where laws and lectures never could.

9. Character Sketches

Hari Singh (The Thief):

  • About 15 years old; intelligent, observant, and street-smart — skills honed by a life of petty crime.
  • Uses a different alias each month and never stays long enough to be caught or known.
  • Skilled at reading people: he quickly judges Anil as an easy, trusting target.
  • Initially morally hollow — theft and deception are habits, not crimes in his own mind.
  • Has a growing conscience: Anil's kindness and the promise of education begin to reshape him from within.
  • At the railway station he makes the hardest choice of his life — to return the money. This marks his moral awakening.
  • Represents young people pulled into dishonesty by circumstance but capable of change when given kindness and opportunity.

Anil:

  • About 25; a writer who earns irregularly — sometimes he has money, sometimes he does not.
  • Easy-going, non-judgmental, and genuinely generous — teaches Hari to cook, read, write, and add, asking nothing in return.
  • Almost certainly knows Hari cheats at the market but says nothing — he trusts in goodness rather than policing behaviour.
  • When the money is returned, he responds not with confrontation but with a fresh, crisp note and a promise of more lessons.
  • Represents the best of human nature — the person who believes in you before you believe in yourself.

10. Message and Values

  • Education is the greatest gift — it gives a person not just knowledge but a new identity and a future worth having.
  • Trust and kindness can reform where punishment fails — Anil never threatens, yet he changes Hari more profoundly than any jail could.
  • Conscience is the most honest judge — Hari is not caught; he catches himself. The story celebrates inner moral strength over external law.
  • No one is beyond redemption — Hari has been a thief all his life, yet one relationship of genuine trust and learning is enough to turn him around.
  • Greed vs. genuine wealth: 600 rupees bought nothing lasting; the ability to read, write, and live honestly is the true wealth.

11. Literary Devices

  • First-person narration: The story is told entirely from the thief's point of view — unusual and effective, placing us inside a criminal's mind and generating sympathy and psychological depth.
  • Irony: The most honest act in the story is committed by the thief. The thief is the one who wrestles most seriously with right and wrong; the “respectable” world around him is largely indifferent.
  • Stream of consciousness: At the railway station, Hari's thoughts flow freely — memories, calculations, fears, and regrets. This reveals his inner moral conflict with great immediacy.
  • Symbolism: The wet, soaked notes symbolise the corruption and worthlessness of stolen money. The crisp, fresh fifty-rupee note Anil gives in the morning symbolises honest earnings and a clean start. Literacy/education symbolises freedom from the cycle of crime and a new identity.
  • Suspense: The reader does not know until the very end whether Hari will run or return — Bond sustains this tension with skill.
  • Understatement: Anil's final words — offering to teach Hari to write whole sentences — carry enormous significance in a single casual sentence.
  • Characterisation through action: Bond shows characters through what they do, not lengthy description. Anil's character is revealed by his laughter when the food fails; Hari's by his decision at the station.

12. Word Meanings

Word / PhraseMeaning
appealingattractive; making one want to help
flatteryexcessive, insincere praise, used to gain something
fairlyto a reasonable degree; quite
grudginglyreluctantly; unwillingly
discardto throw away; to get rid of something unwanted
broodingthinking deeply and sadly about something
edgedmoved slowly and carefully
hospitablefriendly and generous in welcoming guests or others
temptationthe desire to do something wrong or unwise
uneasyanxious; not comfortable or at ease
rustlingmaking a soft, swishing sound (as of paper or leaves)
gratefulfeeling or showing thanks for kindness received
familiarwell known; often encountered before
rewardinggiving a sense of satisfaction or genuine benefit
literateable to read and write
consciencethe inner sense of right and wrong; moral awareness
aliasa false or assumed name used to conceal one's identity
redemptionthe act of making up for past wrongs; being saved from a bad situation
Textbook Questions (Solved)
Q 1. Who is Hari Singh? Why does he keep changing his name?

Hari Singh is the narrator and protagonist — a fifteen-year-old thief. He is not honest about even his name: “Hari Singh” is just the name he is using for this particular month. He keeps changing his name — and moving from place to place — so that the police cannot track him and his previous victims cannot recognise him. This is the habit of an experienced thief who has made deception a way of life. The changing name also symbolises his lack of a stable, honest identity — something he begins to build only when he decides to return Anil's money and continue his education.

Q 2. What does Hari Singh do for Anil, and how does Anil treat him in return?

Hari Singh cooks for Anil and does the daily shopping. He is not a good cook initially; Anil teaches him without scolding — he simply laughs and shows him how. Anil also teaches Hari to read and write words, and to add numbers, all without being asked and without demanding payment. He provides food and shelter, and probably knows Hari cheats at the market but says nothing. This generosity and non-judgmental trust mark Anil as an unusually kind employer and, ultimately, a life-changing figure for Hari.

Q 3. Why does Hari Singh decide to rob Anil? Describe how he carries it out.

When Anil comes home one evening with 600 rupees — money received for a book — and tucks it under the mattress, Hari sees the chance he has been waiting for. Around midnight, after making sure Anil is asleep, Hari carefully slides the bundle of notes out from under the mattress. He feels no guilt at this moment — old habit and his original plan take over. He pockets the 600 rupees, slips quietly out of the room, and walks through the dark city streets heading toward the railway station to catch the Lucknow Express and disappear.

Q 4. What conflict does Hari face at the railway station? What decision does he take?

At the railway station, Hari sits with the stolen notes in hand, ready to board the Lucknow Express. But he cannot make himself get on the train. He is flooded with unexpected thoughts: Anil's easy laughter, the reading lessons, the vision of becoming a literate, respected person. He realises that if he runs, he will always be an uneducated thief with no real future. The rain falls; the notes get wet. After a long inner battle, Hari makes the decision to return. He walks back to Anil's room before dawn and replaces the money under the mattress. This is the story's moral turning point — Hari chooses education and a future over 600 rupees.

Q 5. How does Anil behave the morning after the theft? What does his behaviour reveal?

The morning after Hari returns the money, Anil behaves with complete normalcy. He does not confront Hari, does not mention the money, and does not seem angry. Instead, he gives Hari a fifty-rupee note and says he will now be paid regularly. He also promises to teach Hari to write whole sentences. The fifty-rupee note is crisp and new — not one of the wet notes from under the mattress — which strongly suggests Anil knew what had happened. His response is not anger or punishment but a fresh start: regular pay and more learning. This shows Anil's extraordinary moral maturity — he responds to weakness with trust, not judgment.

Q 6. What is the significance of education in this story?

Education is the central force of moral change. It is not money, fear, or the law that stops Hari from running — it is the thought that he is learning to read and write, and that this is the start of a better life. He realises he could get a real job, earn an honest living, and live as a person with a real name and a real future. Literacy represents dignity and possibility. The 600 rupees offered only a temporary escape; education offers permanence and a new identity. Anil teaching Hari to read is the greatest gift in the story — greater than food, shelter, or even the fifty-rupee note. Bond's message is clear: education can transform a person where punishment cannot.

Extra Questions and Answers
Extra Q 1. How does Hari Singh judge Anil when they first meet? What are his initial intentions?

Hari Singh is a skilled judge of people — it is part of his profession. When he meets Anil at the wrestling match, he quickly assesses him: young (about 25), educated but not rich, easy-going, and trusting. He notices Anil has a “careless” and “appealing” manner. Hari's initial intention is entirely selfish: he attaches himself to Anil as a servant solely to steal from him when the opportunity arises. He sees Anil as a convenient target, not as a person deserving respect. This cold, calculating approach is gradually undone by Anil's unexpected kindness.

Extra Q 2. “He knew I made a little money this way but he did not seem to mind.” What does this line reveal about both characters?

This line reveals two important truths. First, Anil is perceptive — he is not the naive fool Hari initially took him for. He knows about Hari's small cheating at the market. Second, he deliberately chooses to do nothing about it. This is not weakness but a conscious moral choice — to continue trusting Hari, to give him time and space to grow. Anil's trust is not blind; it is conscious and patient. This quiet tolerance is precisely what makes Hari feel the weight of his own dishonesty and makes it impossible for him to betray Anil completely. The line also reveals that Hari himself knows Anil knows — deepening his unease.

Extra Q 3. What is the role of rain at the railway station? Explain its symbolic significance.

Rain is used symbolically at the crisis point of the story. When Hari stands outside the station, it begins to rain. He stands in the rain, getting wet — and the stolen notes in his hand get wet too, turning limp and damaged. The rain has a cleansing, clarifying quality: it strips away the thrill of the theft and leaves Hari alone with his conscience. The wet notes symbolise the corruption and moral worthlessness of stolen money — they literally lose their value. The discomfort of standing in the rain mirrors the internal discomfort of his moral struggle. Rain, in literature, often signals change or purification — here it marks the moment before Hari's transformation.

Extra Q 4. Compare Hari Singh and Anil as characters. How are they similar and different?

Hari Singh is young, street-smart, experienced in deception, and morally adrift at the start. He lives by his wits, changes his name monthly, and sees people as targets. However, he is intelligent and sensitive — he responds to kindness, and his conscience is not dead but suppressed. Anil, by contrast, is educated, generous, easy-going, and morally grounded. He earns irregularly but shares what he has; he teaches not because he is asked but because he believes in it. Both characters are perceptive — Anil knows about the market cheating; Hari knows Anil knows. The difference is what they do with that perception: Hari uses it to exploit; Anil uses it to understand and forgive. This contrast is at the heart of the story.

Extra Q 5 (Extract-based). “I could almost hear Anil breathing in the next room. A click of the latch and I was out. A cold wind whipped up the empty road.” What mood does this create? What does it reveal?

The passage creates a mood of tension, stealth, and a strange loneliness. The darkness, the cold wind, and the empty road suggest moral isolation — Hari is alone with his choice and with the stolen money. The detail of hearing Anil's breathing shows how acutely aware Hari is of Anil even at the moment of betrayal — Anil is not just a victim but a presence in Hari's conscience. The precise, quiet actions (the latch, the cold wind) are written in the manner of a practiced thief, but the very precision also reveals discomfort — there is a tightness in the prose that mirrors Hari's inner conflict. The passage marks the moment just before his conscience fully wakes up.

Extra Q 6. Why does Anil give Hari a crisp new fifty-rupee note the morning after the theft? What does this tell us about Anil?

The crisp, new fifty-rupee note is one of the most telling details in the story. The notes that were under the mattress would have been wet (Hari had taken them into the rain); but the note Anil gives is new and dry. This strongly implies Anil knew the money had been taken and returned. He could have confronted Hari — accused him, dismissed him, or handed him to the police. Instead, he gives him a fresh note and a fresh promise (regular pay and more lessons). This tells us that Anil's kindness is not accidental or naive — it is deliberate and principled. He chooses to respond to Hari's moral struggle with encouragement, not punishment. This final act of trust completes Hari's transformation.

Extra Q 7. What does the story suggest about the power of friendship and human relationships to reform a person?

The story suggests that genuine human connection — especially one built on trust, patience, and generosity — is the most powerful agent of reform. Hari has lived a life of isolation, using different names and moving constantly, treating every person as a target. The relationship with Anil is fundamentally different: for perhaps the first time, Hari is in a relationship where the other person gives without calculation and trusts without conditions. This experience of being genuinely cared for awakens Hari's dormant conscience. He does not change because of a law or a punishment but because he has been shown what a different kind of life feels like — and he finds he wants it. The story is a quiet argument for the reforming power of friendship and human dignity.

Extra Q 8. How does the ending of the story leave the reader with hope?

The ending is quietly but powerfully optimistic. Hari has returned the money; Anil responds not with confrontation but with a fresh fifty-rupee note and a promise of continued teaching. Hari's face has “a little happiness” — the happiness of a person who has done the right thing for the first time. Anil's words — that he will now teach Hari to write whole sentences — point forward: the education will continue, the relationship of trust is intact, and Hari's future is still open. Bond ends on this understated but powerful note of human possibility. The reader is left feeling that Hari will not be a thief much longer — that education and kindness together have turned a corner in his life.

Practice MCQs
1. What is the name the thief gives himself at the start of the story?
  1. Anil
  2. Raju
  3. Hari Singh
  4. He gives no name
Answer: (C) The thief uses the name “Hari Singh” — though he changes his name every month. This is simply the name for that particular time.
2. Where do Hari Singh and Anil first meet?
  1. At a railway station
  2. At a cricket match
  3. At a wrestling match
  4. At a book fair
Answer: (C) They meet at a wrestling match in Delhi.
3. What does Anil do for a living?
  1. He is a teacher
  2. He is a writer who earns irregularly
  3. He is a shopkeeper
  4. He is a police officer
Answer: (B) Anil is a writer; he earns irregularly — sometimes he gets a cheque for an article, sometimes he has very little money.
4. How much money does Hari Singh steal from Anil?
  1. 200 rupees
  2. 400 rupees
  3. 500 rupees
  4. 600 rupees
Answer: (D) Hari steals the 600 rupees Anil received for selling a book.
5. What is the name of the train Hari plans to board to escape?
  1. Rajdhani Express
  2. Lucknow Express
  3. Shatabdi Express
  4. Delhi Mail
Answer: (B) Hari heads to the station to board the Lucknow Express.
6. What prevents Hari from boarding the train?
  1. He is caught by the police
  2. He misses the train
  3. His conscience and the thought of losing his chance at education
  4. He loses the money on the way to the station
Answer: (C) It is his conscience — and the realisation that he is giving up the chance to become educated and lead a better, honest life — that stops him.
7. What happens to the stolen notes while Hari stands outside the railway station?
  1. They are blown away by the wind
  2. They get wet in the rain
  3. They catch fire
  4. They are stolen from him by someone else
Answer: (B) The rain soaks the notes, turning them limp and wet — a symbol of the worthlessness of stolen wealth.
8. The fifty-rupee note Anil gives Hari in the morning is described as “crisp and new.” What does this suggest?
  1. Anil had just gone to the bank
  2. Anil was unaware of the theft
  3. Anil knew the money had been taken and returned, and offered a fresh honest start
  4. Hari had returned only part of the money
Answer: (C) The note being crisp and new (not one of the wet stolen notes) strongly implies Anil knew what had happened but chose to respond with a fresh start rather than confrontation.
9. Which literary device is most prominently used when Hari reflects on his choices at the railway station?
  1. Simile
  2. Stream of consciousness / interior monologue
  3. Alliteration
  4. Onomatopoeia
Answer: (B) Hari's thoughts flow freely at the station — memories, calculations, fears, and regrets — making this a clear example of stream of consciousness or interior monologue.
10. What is the central message of “The Thief's Story”?
  1. Crime always pays if you are clever enough
  2. Trust and education are more powerful than punishment in reforming a person
  3. A thief can never truly change
  4. Money is the most important thing in life
Answer: (B) The story's deepest message is that trust, kindness, and the gift of education can transform a person where laws and punishment cannot.
Previous-Year and Important Board Questions
Board Q 1. “Anil was the most trusting person I had ever met.” Why does Hari say this, and how does Anil's trust affect Hari? (CBSE, 5 marks)

Hari calls Anil the most trusting person he has ever met because Anil never locks his money, never suspects Hari openly, knows about the market cheating and says nothing, and — most powerfully — does not confront Hari even after the 600 rupees are taken and returned. This is absolute, conscious trust. Hari is experienced at working around caution and suspicion — those are familiar defences he can defeat. But absolute trust is something he has never encountered, and he does not know how to steal from someone who trusts completely. Anil's trust follows Hari to the railway station like a conscience made visible — it makes the stolen notes feel worthless and pulls him back before morning. Trust, in this story, is more powerful than any lock, law, or punishment.

Board Q 2. How does Hari's plan to rob Anil go wrong? What does his internal conflict reveal about his character? (CBSE, 5 marks)

Hari's plan is technically flawless — he steals 600 rupees while Anil sleeps and heads to the railway station without being detected. But it goes wrong at the level of conscience. At the station, he is unable to board the train. His internal conflict reveals that beneath the surface of a habitual thief there is a person of sensitivity and moral awareness. He is not merely calculating profit and risk — he is asking “who am I becoming?” The conflict reveals his intelligence (he understands exactly what he is giving up), his emotional depth (he feels Anil's trust like a weight), and his capacity for genuine growth. The fact that he is even having this conflict shows that Anil's kindness has already changed him. A person truly without conscience would simply have boarded the train.

Board Q 3. What role does education play in “The Thief's Story”? Why is it more important than the 600 rupees? (CBSE, 5 marks)

Education in this story is not merely literacy — it is liberation and a new identity. Anil teaches Hari to read words, write, and add numbers. In Hari's mind at the railway station, these lessons translate into a vision: if he can read and write, he can go to an office, get a real job, earn honest money, and live as a person with a real name and a real future. The 600 rupees, on the other hand, would buy him a few weeks of easy living and then require him to find another victim, use another name, and keep running indefinitely. Education offers permanence; the stolen money offers only temporary escape. The choice Hari makes — to return the money and keep learning — shows he has understood this. Bond's story argues powerfully that education is the most transformative gift one person can give another.

Board Q 4. Give a character sketch of Anil. How is he different from other employers Hari has known? (CBSE, 3–5 marks)

Anil is about 25, easy-going, generous, and morally perceptive. He earns irregularly as a writer but shares whatever he has without complaint. He teaches Hari to cook, read, write, and add — asking for nothing in return, not even proper wages. He is different from all of Hari's previous employers in one crucial way: he trusts completely and consciously. He probably knows Hari cheats at the market, and he knows (after the event) that Hari took 600 rupees — but he responds to both with patience and a fresh chance. He does not humiliate, lecture, or punish. This non-judgmental generosity makes Anil impossible to steal from in the deepest sense — because he has already given Hari something more valuable than money. Anil represents the best of human nature: quiet, consistent goodness that asks for nothing and changes everything.

Board Q 5. What is ironic about the title “The Thief's Story”? How does the story subvert our expectations? (Important, 5 marks)

The title creates the expectation of a story about crime, cunning, and perhaps dramatic arrest or confrontation. Instead, Bond gives us something entirely different. The thief does not succeed at his crime — he returns the money himself. There is no police chase, no dramatic exposure. The only confrontation is internal — between the old Hari and the emerging Hari. The irony deepens: the most honest, principled, and morally serious person in the story is the thief himself. He is the one who wrestles most deeply with right and wrong; the world around him is largely indifferent. Bond subverts the genre to turn a story about a criminal into a story about conscience, trust, and moral growth. By the end, the reader is not sure the word “thief” still applies to Hari at all — which is precisely Bond's point.

Want personal coaching in Dwarka?
Book a free demo class
More Class 10 English chapters